In the first major debate of the fall campaign in the VA GOV race on 9/17, national issues took center stage over ex-AG Bob McDonnell's (R) controversial master's thesis giving McDonnell an edge over state Sen. Creigh Deeds (D). Moderated by "Meet The Press"'s David Gregory and a panel of local journalists, the pair squared off before a couple hundred local businesspeople and a live online audience at the Capital One world headquarters in McLean, VA. The debate was sponsored by the Fairfax County Chamber of Commerce.
Here are the central storylines from the debate:
The Incredible Shrinking Thesis
The first question posed by Gregory was about McDonnell's thesis. The "Meet The Press" host asked McDonnell to explain specifically how his views have changed since it was published. The question was a hard-hitting one, but McDonnell deftly evaded it with a stories of how proud he was of his "working mom" wife and daughter Amy, whose service in Iraq he said made her "the ultimate working woman."
In short, McDonnell has his talking points down about the thesis. The same can't be said of Deeds, who actually appeared to hit a road block when reeling off his talking points on the document. Deeds definitely tried to keep the story alive, returning to the thesis again and again during the debate, and even scored some some points with it at one point after McDonnell attacked Deeds' union support. "We know now that he doesn't support working women," Deeds said. "But what does he have against working families?"
Overall, though, it was clear that McDonnell was confident in his line of defense. And that was bad news for Deeds, who kept poking at McDonnell with cultural issues, but wasn't able to score more than a glancing blow.
Face The Nation
National issues were front and center at the debate, with moderators grilling both candidates about cap and trade, health care, the environment and what do to with Guantanamo Bay detainees. As is probably no surprise, McDonnell was much more comfortable taking on these topics than Deeds was. The GOPer slammed WH policies over and over, and waited as Deeds scrambled to navigate a treacherous path between standing by a president that's popular with Dems and standing apart from policies that are unpopular with independents and moderates.
A key moment came during a discussion of Pres. Obama. Gregory asked Deeds, "are you an Obama Democrat?"
Deeds told a story of his early years in VA politics ex-Sen. Chuck Robb (D) and ex-Gov. Douglas Wilder were "feuding."
"Everyone would ask me, 'are you a Wilder Democrat or a Robb Democrat?'" Deeds said. "To deflect them, I'd say 'I'm a Creigh Deeds Democrat.'"
Pressed on the question, Deeds eventually said, "I like [Obama] personally. He's smart and innovative. I'm a Creigh Deeds Democrat."
Extremist Is In The Eyes Of The Beholder
It is currently illegal for a same sex couple to jointly adopt a child in VA. Asked if the law should be changed, both men agreed that the state's current statutes -- which allow a single parents to adopt regardless of sexual orientation (but not without the approval of the gov't) -- was enough. Deeds seemed eager to drop the topic though, saying "I leave it up to the decision of the courts in every situation" before changing the subject to right to work laws.
McDonnell was more comfortable talking about the issue, firmly stating that VA law says it is best that a heterosexual couple is "the best" environment for a child, but also agreeing that the law allowing for single parent adoptions was a good one. "I think Creigh and I agree on this one," he said quickly.
The exchange shows the limits of the "culture warrior" line of attack Deeds has been using against McDonnell. Though Deeds was not as adamant about the reasons for VA's gay adoption ban as McDonnell was, he wasn't willing to alienate more conservative voters with an overtly pro-gay rights stand.
The Plan Is The Plan
Transportation, not surprisingly, was a prominent part of the debate.
As he has throughout the summer, McDonnell pushed his detailed transportation plan. Deeds, on the other hand, focused on a promise to build the bipartisan coalition necessary to finally get transportation done. Two different approaches, one result -- neither man scored solid hits on transportation. McDonnell was awkward in explaining the financial details of his plan, while Deeds focused on the things he wouldn't do, like taking money from the general fund or education.
McDonnell again promised not to raise any taxes. Deeds made the same promise -- but also said he was open to new funding streams that included drivers paying for the roads they use.
Parting Shots
For a debate billed by the Deeds camp on a 9/16 press call as key for their candidate, today's clash failed to deliver. The arguments fell along familiar rhetorical lines, and neither man was able to pull away. McDonnell emerged largely unscathed, which in Dem leaning NoVa is a victory.
(EVAN McMORRIS-SANTORO)